|
Pretty and Injured: the Contemporary
Art
of China in the Late 1990s
By Zhu Qi
1. the cultural characteristics in the post-political
society
From 1949 to the end of 1980s, the society in China has been
such a political society defined by Grancy and then it has
been transformed into a post-political society in 1990s.
In the earlier stage of 1990s, the industry and capital concepts
with the economic liberalization as their characteristics
have brought about the re-structuring of the society in China.
The politics has been transformed into a post-ideological
organizational system and the establishment of the commerce
and pop culture on the daily levels in the society in China
has pushed the society of China forward into a post-political
and cultural formation.
In 1990s, the society in China was also regarded as "the
Red Heaven" in a sense of new Leftists. It has a new
Leftist colour with a consumer trend of the Hedonism, i.e.
trying to integrate the Leftist ideological system with the
material consumption and the free market in 1990s, thus forming
the cultural characteristics of the post-socialist concepts
with the Chinese features. On one hand, the society of China
has the cultural characteristics of the post-ideological system,
on the other hand, the rapid globalization and commercialization
in such fields as the propagation, commerce, the international
trade and entertainments have taken place in the society of
China. The unusual and unbelievable transformation has granted
the social structures and the cultural background of China
a completely new nature which is different from both the socialism
and the capitalism. Whether the political centralization of
powers, the capitalism or the classical thinking, all of them
have the possibility of transformation into a new times of
peace.
In the late 1990s, the essential transformations of the visual
arts are embodied in the routinization and the visual symbolization.
The routinization and the new features of the post-political
society is a very important theme in China of the late 1990s.
Some of the young artists began to focus their attentions
on the new ideas of life in the public space and the routinization
of the indoor life which have been brought by the social transformations.
They have depicted both the politics of the public consumption
which came from the innermost recesses of lust in the 1990s
and the ego crux arising from their deep involvement in the
lust of the young generation. For the social contents, such
an original theme has represented the end of the form of duality
including the visual symbols of the politics and the absolute
formalism with the artistic relationship in the period of
the political society of 1980s. At the same time it also symbolizes
the beginning of the contemporary art in China.
Its contemporary nature lies in a point that the young generation
will never follows any ideology. "Waiting for the Sunshine"
is the basic theme of the new Utopian visions in 1990s. "What
to Get" seems unclear, but "Escaping from the Sufferings"
is an absolute psychological requirement. Such a requirement
is granted a new romantic color by the favourable advantages
of materials provided in the era of the capitalism.
The typical tendency of the contemporary art in the late
1990s in China is the fashionable and vogue visual images
and the contents of schizophrenia, which have embodied the
new characteristics of their personal experiences and visual
favours of the generation. It is depicted as the heart of
their sentiments in a form of the fabricate agony. The agony
is not like the visual hostile targets in the early stage
of the capitalism: capitalists, merchandise, machines and
money. These symbols have already lost their orientations
of criticism ethically. Accompanied by a pretty sense of visualization
and the insignificance that the life cannot endure, this generation
has felt injured, but cannot find the origin of injuries.
This characteristics has not only brought about a psychological
aftereffect of a generation in the transformation period of
the political society, but also become a basic theme of the
visual arts in the late 1990s. It has embodied their visual
descriptions of the new "Red Heaven", cognition,
expression of sufferings and psychotherapy.
The re-confirmation of the political system of symbolization
and the re-emergence of its variants is another important
tendency of the contemporary art in the late 1990s. the generation
born around 1960s can be regarded as a carrier of the visual
system of the red revolution in the 1990s. Compared to such
a system, the presentation of the new life in 1990s is a different
or completely opposite "alienation" in a politically
symbolic significance. The identification of the significance
of the alienation can be classified as a post-subject action.
It has confirmed the failure of the metaphysically symbolic
system of visual images, but it has no alternative symbolic
system to establish the formal significance of the daily images.
In the eyes of Delaz, the post-subject is a "wanderer",
or a "surplus subject". It has fled from the metaphysical
system of the "Heaven" and become a vagrant. This
is also the inner status of the generation who were born around
1960s.
The art is a post-subject art in the 1990s and its visual
spirit is uncertain in moral and political contents. During
the period, China, as a society with limited openness, is
only able to grant the people such hopes as follows: the opportunity
to start a business to become a middle bourgeoisie and wealthy
man, the liberalization of the markets, the gradual break-down
of such social taboos as sex and politics, the possibility
of crazy consumption, and etc and the post-political society
in the 1990s is provided with an acceptable legality. The
ideology has transformed into a form of social control. In
the political arena, the elite politics have been transformed
into the politics of the pop culture and such a post-ideology
is the basic characteristics of the artistic background in
the late 1990s.
On the whole, it is very difficult for the people to express
the complexity of the social and cultural transformations
in China in a single model about the political society or
globalized evolutions. Just as the complexity of the contemporary
culture in the North American commercial visual structures
described in the film of "Matrix, it almost includes
all of the alienations for the public consumption: the visual
images with computer science and technology, the theme of
saving the Christianity, the Kongfu Style of Hong Kong, the
shooting of MTV and the naturalist scences (subways, slum
buildings and drug addicts).
2. the unusual images of "the Red Heaven"
The revelations of the new unusual images and the re-confirmations
of the symbolic systems of politics in the 1980s have played
an important role in the art of the late 1990s. It is carried
out around the imagery experiences and the variations of explanations.
Basically speaking, in the late 1990s, the new "Heaven"
landscape in a market-socialism China is a moral image in
the visual arts in a broad sense. Such two unconscious levels
as the uncertainty of the moral significance and the fantastic
acceptance of the beauty are no other than the descriptions
of the unusual environment and the poetry.
In comparison with the education background of the 1980s
(the Leftist ideology, the revolting culture of the young
generation in the late 1960s, the avant-garde and modernism),
it is no doubt that MacDonald's, bars, the fashionable girls,
the electronic games, sex and more is the unusual image of
the new culture. Since 1998, Zhong Biao has been making his
efforts to integrate the presentations of the new life with
the symbolic system of culture and politics into an unusual
realm of the post-political society. The new skyscrapers in
Shanghai, the Western beauties, the Red Guards, the symbol
of MacDonald, the furniture of the Ming and Qing Dynasties,
and the images on the restructuring of the spirit of Lei Feng
in a religious sense have highlighted the important background
which was taking shape in the society of the late 1990s in
China: the post-modern public ideology. Not only the globalized
product industry has provided the contemporary society a rich
material life, but also, as a fabricate industry of a fashionable
culture, the global consultancy industry has been replacing
the concepts of intellectuals, the abstract influences of
charts and grammar in a materialized and perceptional means.
Although almost 20 years later than the West, such a change
has turned China into an alien world with imaginations in
quite a short time in the late 1990s.
How does the body emerge from under the coat of the symbols
of ideology and move towards the perceptual, routine and materialized
life. The post-modernist sculptures of Liu Jianhua have presented
the basic styles and contents on a daily base after the post-political
society was established in the late 1990s. His works have
displayed a new historical attitude: the contemporary art
is unavoidably the side products of the special system of
the society and the definition of the art in a political society
did not have any essential changes in the 1990s. The expressions
of such basic imagery as the symbolic objects, limbs and styles
have a evolutive relationship in languages with the background
of the 1980s, whether these backgrounds have already disappeared
in the past, or still exist behind the objects at present.
For example, sofas, bath tubes, the flirtatious postures of
ladies--sitting, lying and prone positions. Even the fashionable
qipao in the period of colonized Shanghai in 1930s is also
the bourgeoisie symbols to be prohibited in the period of
the political society. By the 1990s, they have reflected the
re-comprehension of the proletarians in the post-political
society and their new Utopian visions. In 1999, Liu Jianhua
began to place the bodies in the indoor landscape composed
of sofas, bath tubes, woman and fashionable qipaos and the
bodies was introduced into the forms of routinization and
dramatization and have a fabulous quality. They have brought
to light the reasons and experiences of the self through the
dramatic auxiliaries on the daily basis.
The post-modern sculptures of Liu Jianhua are depicted visually
as the imitations of the photographic works. For the impressions
of the photographic works, the models or the prop-like scales
strengthened the visual dramatization of the fables. Its ceramic
luster conforms to the sentiments of the post-political society:
the tranquility, intoxication and the sense of freedom that
the Chinese people have regained have hinted that such an
unrestrictedness has play an important part in the formation
and stability of the post-political society of China in 1990s.
There is no negation of the political society of the 1980s
behind the sluggishness, affectedness and imitations of coquette.
It (the body) has its own orientation and perceptual power
coming from itself. The body which acted in symbolic coatings
has already come to its end in the 1990s, i.e. they have already
disappeared as a visual symbol of the capitalist significance,
but they have not established a definite symbolic significance
of the post-socialism. Therefore, they are listed as the other
category which have a sense of freshness, but no symbolic
significance.
Around 1998, Xu Yihui put the fast-food boxes, RMB and Quotations
from Chairman Mao together and change them into a pop sculpture.
The three elements have embodied the psychological manifestations
full of perceptual anxiety in the symbolic re-confirmations:
materialization, commercialization and fast-foodization is
unacceptable while materialization, commercialization and
fast-foodization is also acceptable. The former is the existing
reactions from the education background of the 1980s and the
latter is from the human infatuation of the 1990s.
There is a Lakanian connections of unconciousness with the
images in the semantic relationship of Xu Yihui. The nature
of images of fast food is the outer imagery of money and the
latter is a symbolic object of opposition and hostility against
the symbolic significance of the "Red Treasured Books".
Xu's somnambulistic expressions of the objects in the consumer
society have manifested that the visualization used in the
society and symbolized political system is just the beginning
of the inner transformations in individuals, i.e. the concrete
and materialized imagery are granted a definite orientation
of symbolization and orders and degrees (high class and low
class, the obverse and the reverse, and etc.) within the political
and social systems of China in the 1980s. Entering the 1990s,
not only the positions of the images have been reversed in
the symbolic orders of significance, but also the expressions
have never been proved metaphysically, but by the bodies.
This is a post-subjectivity: the critics of the principal
consumers constitute a part of the principal consumers. If
the subjectivity is for lust and utility, then, the post-subjectivity
is relative with the nature of body, the moral confirmation
of lust and the subject of materialized positivism and its
language or the visual significance itself is relative with
the adaptation of interest and objects.
In the visual arts of the 1990s, the expressions of the post-subjectivity
lie in the re-establishment of a subject by sampling of new
and different images and historicizing and practicing the
images of the Leftist culture which have been existing since
the 1960s. the "On the Way" expressions in search
of a new "Red Heaven" is not the heaven, but a different
realm in search of the heaven and the nomadic poetry.
During the 1990s, Liu Dahong tried his efforts to re-compile
a imagery system for the politics of the red revolution in
a way of visual atlas and grant a scene of the red heaven
like a new fairy tale. "A Tale of Two Cities", created
in 1998, integrated Paris during the French Revolution and
Shanghai During the Cultural Revolution into "a City
of Heaven" of the young infatuations. "A Tale of
Two Cities" is same as a narration of the illustrated
history of exodus about the modern tales of revolutionary.
It is a narrator of the spirit of the great revolutionary
tale as an illustrated allusion of the politics.
As a post-political artworks, "A Tale of Two Cities"
of Liu Dahong has represented their suffering and memories
of the generation of the 1960s in a way of psychological hiatus
because they had an experience of the Utopia, revolution and
divinity in the Leftist tides as an experience in "the
Red Heaven". He has been trying to fabricate the experiences
and a psychological theme of a young generation in a Utopian
era of revolution, i.e. on the magic power, the Lost Eden
and the daydream spirit, in order to identify the modernity.
Liu's creations have represented the influences of the deep-rooted
ideological education of the generation and there exist a
Utopian spirit with the abstract and post-ideological characteristics
against the background. He has been trying to confirm the
influences of ideology on the social morality and the living
imagination from a historical angle of the contemporary spirit.
As for reviewing the imagery system of the Leftist history
and politics, a representative is an imitation of the classical
painting of politics by Wang Xingwei, "Mao Zedong to
Anyuan". Wang Xingwei painted himself on the position
of Mao Zedong in the classical painting. It is a definite
characteristics of the post-politics to insert an individual
subjectivity in a position of the fabricated history.
The experimental drama of Wang Jianwei accompanied with the
video art of the drama has also reflected the influences on
our deep memories by the psychological visualization of the
political society in the late 1990s.
As a matter of fact, the new imagery of life in the post-political
society and the visions of the red revolution have been observed
in a confused and multilevel system of cultures in the 1990s.
As for the points of view that the visions of different images
are that the Chinese art has fallen into the pit of the comprehensive
reactions of psychology in the period of the political transformations.
The influences come from different levels: the reality of
globalization with internet, the financial system of capital
and the transnational corporations is at a level, China, as
a representative of the Asian society, is an important part
with the example of the natural adaptation of the Asian society
to the post-modern commercial carnivals. Their direct characteristics
of culture come from their infatuation in the actual world
without any subject for a post-political society. In addition
to this, the contemporary art of China has been introduced
into a grand imaginative system in the 1990s. Such a system
involves the participation of Europe, North America, Australia
and the East Asia--they imagine how China looks like and how
the future of China will be. At the imaginative level, China
is regarded both as an indicator which produces ideological
thinking and as a political and material reality.
In the 1990s, "the native land" and "the nationalization"
have been upgraded as a concept which is used of our own will
and the identity and practices have crossed the boundaries
of the regions by and by. This includes that the young Chinese
artists have been traveling by Boeing airplanes for the international
art biennial all around the world. For example, Ma Liuming
made physical contacts with the people from different regions
in the European and Asian exhibition halls, presenting the
global applications of sex and nakedness. But the body performance
of Ma Liuming is still regarded as the post-ideology in China.
This is the very difference that cannot be remedied by flying
a Boeing between China and Europe and North America.
3. Analysis of Youth Self-symptom
In late 90s,China modern art began to focus on the problem
of self-symptom of the 90s' transitional period. In a sense,
the self-symptom is just an expression of self-inadaptation
caused by social changes from spiritual supreme and elite
guide to material consumption and revelry of popular art.
In fact people is inadaptable not to the social realities
but to the presentation of the other category, symbols and
new life, and the variation of the cultural explanation .
This kind of self-inadaptation caused by the social transition
also existed in basic concepts of value such as politics and
moral. In the 90s' modern Chinese art, an important trend
was that self-anxiety and spiritual symptom contained in the
new realistic presentation used to be expressed by realistic
creative methods, in another word, the art have the value
of the depth psychology of self-transition in materialized
periods.
In late 90s', another important trend--establishment of individual
subject and revelation of privacy emerged. The earliest clue
could be found in the early 90s' paintings of new generation
represented by Liu Xiaodong . The paintings,finished by those
who are still in youth, belong to "the subject of youth"
that is on an earlier depiction and summary of adolescence
experience and world view. The main theme can be divided into
three categories: angry youth, injuried children and worried
intellectuals. In a sense, the 90s' art of "subject of
youth" expressed more ideas of youth than the 70s' literature
of school graduates, the latter in fact was just the memory
and rethinking of past youth by adults.
In earlier 90s, painter Xi Haizhou began to portray the generation
of 60s' who were indulged in the electronic games. He aimed
at either a gang of young people playing billiards or playing
electronic games. The general appearence of Xi's painting
emphasizes the degree of the distance and the quality of no
exchange between the creator and objects, he and those young
people seem close but can not be closer. The gaming youth
were always be portrayed as "the other category"
or stranger different from the popular. Up to the late 90s',
these youth in Xi's paintings became a set of larger faces
and exaggerated eyes, and the faces and eyes were laden with
little grief or in a trance. In Xi's paintings the youth are
" the other category" or "new youth "
that can't be explained and difficult to ascertain.
The "youth" series of Xi Haizhou paintins try to
surpass the limits of photography, so in his works endless
exaggerated faces show more realistic affects of feelings
than photography. The apperance of pictures seems to express
a visual spirit analysis, and because the objective is hard
to understand, the author's uneasiness covers the entire appearence
of the picture. Sometimes facial expression of the picture
seems a symbol of self-analysis and information transmition.
In a word, Xi Haizhou gives a picture of this generation's
fragility, loss of inner heart, and specific sink and unsaved
sorrow.
The art of youth subject leans to self-exposure in order
to discover a psychological baseline. It is always based on
the body parts in post political society, revealing the ill-treat,
illusion, game and self-sorrow in the daily life. When a generation
abandons the past, they would be uneasy for the psychological
change, and At this time, he needs to see himself as an object.
This is a creative way of fable.
Injuries is basic youth subject of late 90s'. Since 1998,
Xie Nanxing has created a seris of fables attempting to tell
an cruel instance of a conflict bretween children and adults,
and just this instance gives much unforgettable brutal visual
memorial. Xie's words is ironical, a brutal scene is covered
by a hazy poetic favor. Injuries and growing up are still
steady subject of post political society, Xie Nanxing portrays
the basic symptoms of the generation: more sensitive, more
cruelly being hurt but more hard to find why being hurt.
The same subject could be found in 1999 sculpturesque environment
arrangements making up by young sculptor Qing Ga. The works
dipicts naked men and women in a hopeless and depressing bathroom,
having self-comfort, suiciding or lying deathly. The cruel
image of the works of Qing Ga and Xie Nanxing is combined
with touching poetic favor and beauty.This is a visual characteristics
of youth subject of late 90s'.
In 1998, young female paiter Yang Fan began to portray the
girls in southern Chinese towns. These girls were fashional,
heavily made up, smoking cigarettes and modeling for the movie
stars. The urban materilized girls of late 90s in Yang Fan's
paintings with the portrait nature of depth psychology, are
just same as west capitalist countries. Even countryside girls
are just same. They like to use internationalized cosmetics,
chothes and other products. It is more important that their
illusion is concerted, for example, they model for the same
beauty, learn from the urban struggle stories, have the same
thought of success, and are influenced by the US and Asian
capitalist popular industry. Yan's painting reveal the fantascy
of young females in the period of transition--to save themselve
by possessing a materialized life and industrial products.
These girls whose regional difference and countryside characteristics
are losing has a internationalized qualities: temptation for
other places, free making up and excited for pleasure, to
be as beautiful as others, entering a strange crowd, casting
themselve into a fictional Utopia,and cutting the link with
past life. These girls are even more open than those in Beijing
and Shanghai. Even living in the countryside, they could know
the story between Clinton and Lewinskey. Many girls go beyond
the regional, set up the knowledge of post industrial culture
and are filled with fantascy for other place.
Yan Fan's paintings relay an unconcious self-recall when
global culture and capitalist populur culture have a great
impact on the next generation. Her theme is about influenced
sorrow and influenced road to liberation.
The photograph taken by Zhen Guogu is just like a ducument
about modenization and commerialization and internationalization
of Chinese towns. He took the photograph of the scene of the
streets and daily life of young people of Yangjiang a town
near GuangZhou. Yangjiang youth, much influenced by the popular
culture of HK,Japan and the US like the girls in Yang Fan's
painting, like to have hair dyed, are dressed fashionally
and engage in business. Zheng put together all kinds of photograghs
with automatic camera taken by young people there, Zheng gave
us a complete picture of life and youth reminisnce of young
people in town. Yangjiang youth is just an epitome of all
Chinese youth in small town in late 90s', they quickly finished
transition from town youth to internationalized youth.
The creatives by Li Zhangyang reveal another realistic part
of Chinese society under the system of post ideology. His
sculptures reflecting private life and street scenics of 90s'
common people has a new realistic spirit: the "San Pei
Girls"(bar girls) series involves the scene of playing
Mahjong, massage house, haircutting, singing Karaoke and so
on, and street series with ceremony opening in street, administrators
and pedlarsks, and fighting in street. All the works reflect
the conflict of community interests, life struggle and maddness
of human nature. His scultpures are imbued with boyish youth
curiosity of"heaven cinema", pure peek excitement
and self-baffle.
The photographic words of Yang Fudong have a thicker youthful
flavor of little intellectuals. His photography is an simulated
play of a scene, reflecting the inward change of little intellectuals
because of uncertainty of their status transition to modern
white collars. In 2000, his work "the first intellectual"
fictioned an image of an angry youth: a white collar youngman,
dressed in bloody torn suite, is stanging on the avenue at
the finance ane trade district, and attempts to fight desperately
with bricks in hands. Yang Fudong reflects a picture that
young intellectuals suffer the inward injury after the entrance
of capitalism to China.
The 3D-film"the rock on the road of new long march"
which was created by young artist Lao Jiang should be an outstanding
video art in late 90s. He reinterpreted the rock music of
Cui Jian with visual measures. The film shows the youthful
unrestrained qualities of the latest generation in post political
society. This "Internet" generation seems not to
take everything seriously.
In late 90s of China, the most influential creatives should
be those made by li Zhangyang and Yan Fan. Their main works
had a significent impact on youthful aesthetic standard, life
style and word view. In fact, the 90s' deeper reforms was
enormously influential to Chinese modern art. In this environment,
the artists themsevle not only could receive a lot of new
visual resources and aesthetic experiences but also influenced
and changed directly. In reality, both the influenced self-predicament
and ideological self-symptom had become an important theme
which is mainly about the material life and self-analysis.
The theme is embodied in the 90s' political cultural revolution,
so the modern art finds a cultural expression to meet the
demand of public consumptions and political balances which
in a broad sense should be a kind of post political cultural
concepts; the basis of post cultural lies in reslism of moral
and politics. The cultural features in late 90s' is the philosophical
and aesthetic return and concrete expression, because the
social discussion about abstract ideology has gone away. At
this point, the self-expression from a personal view is a
valuable exit. The cultural features of post politics -- materialization,
show of body and perceptiveness become a blueprint of new
red heaven designers. So self-return in late 90s' is almost
an escape of new generation to a secret kingdom.
In early 90s, the new generation art revealed intellectual
seriosness after lose of Utopia and pained romantics. up to
late 90s, when post capitalism thoroughly went into China,
unfinished youth combined with a hope for capitalist good
life, self-moral anxiety and inward injury in modern commercial
system after extreme politics became an obvious feature that
was different from earlier "post new generation".
The late 90s' art with emphasis on beautiful appearence and
inward injury is a continuousness of the "post new generation".
|